Literature detail

Coronavirus testing indicates transmission risk increases along wildlife supply chains for human consumption in Viet Nam, 2013-2014.

Nguyen Quynh Huong1 Nguyen Thi Thanh Nga1 Nguyen Van Long2 Bach Duc Luu2 Alice Latinne1,3,4 Mathieu Pruvot3 Nguyen Thanh Phuong5 Le Tin Vinh Quang5 Vo Van Hung5 Nguyen Thi Lan6 Nguyen Thi Hoa6 Phan Quang Minh2 Nguyen Thi Diep2 Nguyen Tung2 Van Dang Ky2 Scott I Roberton1 Hoang Bich Thuy1 Nguyen Van Long1 Martin Gilbert3 Leanne Wicker1 Jonna A K Mazet7 Christine Kreuder Johnson7 Tracey Goldstein7 Alex Tremeau-Bravard7 Victoria Ontiveros7 Damien O Joly3 Chris Walzer3,8 Amanda E Fine1,3 Sarah H Olson3
Affiliations 8 institutions
  1. Wildlife Conservation Society, Viet Nam Country Program, Ha Noi, Viet Nam.
  2. Department of Animal Health, Ministry of Agricultural and Rural Development of Viet Nam, Ha Noi, Viet Nam.
  3. Wildlife Conservation Society, Health Program, Bronx, New York, United States of America.
  4. EcoHealth Alliance, New York, New York, United States of America.
  5. Regional Animal Health Office No. 6, Ho Chi Minh City, Viet Nam.
  6. Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Viet Nam National University of Agriculture, Ha Noi, Viet Nam.
  7. One Health Institute, School of Veterinary Medicine, University of California, Davis, California, United States of America.
  8. Research Institute of Wildlife Ecology, University of Veterinary Medicine, Vienna, Austria.
PMID 32776964 2020 PLoS One eng epublish
PubMed DOI Browse context

Article

Publication summary

Outbreaks of emerging coronaviruses in the past two decades and the current pandemic of a novel coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2) that emerged in China highlight the importance of this viral family as a zoonotic public health threat. To gain a better understanding of coronavirus presence and diversity in wildlife at wildlife-human interfaces in three southern provinces in Viet Nam 2013-2014, we used consensus Polymerase Chain Reactions to detect coronavirus sequences. In comparison to previous studies, we observed high proportions of positive samples among field rats (34.0%, 239/702) destined for human consumption and insectivorous bats in guano farms (74.8%, 234/313) adjacent to human dwellings. Most notably among field rats, the odds of coronavirus RNA detection significantly increased along the supply chain from field rats sold by traders (reference group; 20.7% positivity, 39/188) by a factor of 2.2 for field rats sold in large markets (32.0%, 116/363) and 10.0 for field rats sold and served in restaurants (55.6%, 84/151). Coronaviruses were also detected in rodents on the majority of wildlife farms sampled (60.7%, 17/28). These coronaviruses were found in the Malayan porcupines (6.0%, 20/331) and bamboo rats (6.3%, 6/96) that are raised on wildlife farms for human consumption as food. We identified six known coronaviruses in bats and rodents, clustered in three Coronaviridae genera, including the Alpha-, Beta-, and Gammacoronaviruses. Our analysis also suggested either mixing of animal excreta in the environment or interspecies transmission of coronaviruses, as both bat and avian coronaviruses were detected in rodent feces on wildlife farms. The mixing of multiple coronaviruses, and their apparent amplification along the wildlife supply chain into restaurants, suggests maximal risk for end consumers and likely underpins the mechanisms of zoonotic spillover to people.

Animals Animals, Wild Chiroptera Coronavirus Coronavirus Infections Disease Reservoirs Feces Food Supply Humans Meat Phylogeny Polymerase Chain Reaction Porcupines Rats Risk RNA, Viral Vietnam Zoonoses

Structured evidence records

Evidence records

11 total
4 records
Extraction confidence 0.80
Key finding

Coronavirus detection rates increased along the field rat trade-to-market-to-restaurant wildlife supply chain in Viet Nam, showing ecological amplification and elevated transmission risk at human consumption interfaces.

Location
Supporting text

We observed high proportions of positive samples among field rats (34.0%, 239/702) destined for human consumption and insectivorous bats in guano farms (74.8%, 234/313) adjacent to human dwellings. Most notably among field rats, the odds of coronavirus RNA detection significantly increased along the supply chain from field rats sold by traders (20.7%) to large markets (32.0%) and restaurants (55.6%), indicating amplification along the wildlife supply chain.

Method
Polymerase Chain Reaction; field sampling
Sample type
feces
Geographic raw
Viet Nam
Country inferred
Vietnam
Extraction confidence 0.80
Key finding

Insectivorous bats in guano farms adjacent to human dwellings in Viet Nam showed high coronavirus positivity, suggesting reservoir persistence at wildlife–human interfaces.

Host
Location
Supporting text

High proportions of positive samples were observed among insectivorous bats in guano farms (74.8%, 234/313) adjacent to human dwellings, indicating potential maintenance or reservoir dynamics at bat–human interfaces.

Method
Polymerase Chain Reaction; field sampling
Sample type
feces
Geographic raw
Viet Nam
Country inferred
Vietnam
Extraction confidence 0.80
Key finding

Malayan porcupines and bamboo rats raised on wildlife farms in Viet Nam tested positive for coronaviruses, indicating the presence of reservoir or maintenance host dynamics within the farm environment.

Location
Supporting text

Coronaviruses were also detected in rodents on the majority of wildlife farms sampled (60.7%, 17/28). These coronaviruses were found in the Malayan porcupines (6.0%, 20/331) and bamboo rats (6.3%, 6/96) that are raised on wildlife farms for human consumption as food.

Method
Polymerase Chain Reaction; field sampling
Sample type
feces
Geographic raw
Viet Nam
Country inferred
Vietnam
Extraction confidence 0.80
Key finding

Detection of bat and avian coronaviruses in rodent feces on wildlife farms indicates environmental mixing and potential interspecies viral exchange within the farm ecology.

Host
Location
Supporting text

Our analysis also suggested either mixing of animal excreta in the environment or interspecies transmission of coronaviruses, as both bat and avian coronaviruses were detected in rodent feces on wildlife farms.

Method
Polymerase Chain Reaction; field sampling
Sample type
feces
Geographic raw
Viet Nam
Country inferred
Vietnam
4 records
Extraction confidence 1.00
Key finding

Surveillance in southern Viet Nam found that coronavirus positivity in field rats increased along the wildlife supply chain for human consumption.

Location
Supporting text

High proportions of positive samples were observed among field rats (34.0%, 239/702) destined for human consumption, with coronavirus RNA detection increasing along the supply chain from traders to markets to restaurants in southern Viet Nam.

Method
Polymerase Chain Reaction
Sample type
feces
Geographic raw
southern provinces in Viet Nam
Country inferred
Vietnam
Extraction confidence 1.00
Key finding

Coronavirus RNA was frequently detected in insectivorous bats from guano farms near human dwellings in Viet Nam.

Host
Location
Supporting text

Insectivorous bats in guano farms (74.8%, 234/313) adjacent to human dwellings were also coronavirus-positive.

Method
Polymerase Chain Reaction
Sample type
feces
Geographic raw
southern provinces in Viet Nam
Country inferred
Vietnam
Extraction confidence 1.00
Key finding

Surveillance on wildlife farms in Viet Nam detected coronaviruses in Malayan porcupines and bamboo rats raised for human consumption.

Location
Supporting text

Coronaviruses were also detected in rodents on the majority of wildlife farms sampled (60.7%, 17/28). These coronaviruses were found in Malayan porcupines (6.0%, 20/331) and bamboo rats (6.3%, 6/96) raised on wildlife farms for human consumption.

Method
Polymerase Chain Reaction
Sample type
feces
Geographic raw
southern provinces in Viet Nam
Country inferred
Vietnam
Extraction confidence 1.00
Key finding

Detection of coronavirus RNA in bamboo rats raised on wildlife farms in Viet Nam.

Location
Supporting text

Coronaviruses were found in bamboo rats (6.3%, 6/96) raised on wildlife farms for human consumption.

Method
Polymerase Chain Reaction
Sample type
feces
Geographic raw
southern provinces in Viet Nam
Country inferred
Vietnam
1 records
Extraction confidence 0.85
Key finding

Bat and avian coronaviruses were detected in rodent feces on wildlife farms in Viet Nam, indicating potential interspecies transmission between bats or birds and rodents.

Location
Supporting text

Our analysis also suggested either mixing of animal excreta in the environment or interspecies transmission of coronaviruses, as both bat and avian coronaviruses were detected in rodent feces on wildlife farms.

Method
Polymerase Chain Reaction; phylogenetic analysis
Study design
field surveillance
Transmission direction
animal-to-animal
Geographic raw
Viet Nam
Country inferred
Vietnam
1 records
Extraction confidence 0.70
Key finding

Six known coronaviruses detected in bats and rodents were classified into Alpha-, Beta-, and Gammacoronavirus genera based on sequence data from consensus PCR.

Location
Not specified
Supporting text

We used consensus Polymerase Chain Reactions to detect coronavirus sequences... We identified six known coronaviruses in bats and rodents, clustered in three Coronaviridae genera, including the Alpha-, Beta-, and Gammacoronaviruses.

Analysis methods
consensus PCR; phylogenetic analysis
1 records
Extraction confidence 0.90
Key finding

Coronaviruses detected in bats and rodents along wildlife supply chains in Viet Nam were amplified toward the end-consumer stage, indicating likely zoonotic spillover to humans consuming wild animals.

Location
Supporting text

The mixing of multiple coronaviruses, and their apparent amplification along the wildlife supply chain into restaurants, suggests maximal risk for end consumers and likely underpins the mechanisms of zoonotic spillover to people.

Method
Polymerase Chain Reaction
Study design
field surveillance
Transmission direction
animal-to-human
Geographic raw
Viet Nam
Country inferred
Vietnam